Never reveal your current salary when asked about salary expectations. Instead, get the employer to share their range first, then use criteria-based questions to position yourself at the top. Most professionals lose thousands before the offer is even written because they anchor themselves too low, too early.
"What are your salary expectations?"
It sounds straightforward. It is not. It is the single most consequential moment in your entire interview process, and most people get it wrong by anchoring themselves too low, too early.
I have conducted over 9,000 executive interviews and helped professionals negotiate more than $30 million in combined salaries. This one question explains why many strong candidates end up underpaid.
This article was originally recorded as a video. You can watch the full episode on YouTube if you prefer.
Why should you never reveal your current salary?
Your current salary has zero relevance to what the role is worth today. Disclosing it does three things, all of them bad.
It anchors the conversation around your history, not your value. It gives the employer a ceiling they did not earn. And it signals that you are negotiating from a position of need rather than strength.
Your goal in every salary conversation is the same: get them to reveal the range first.
What should you say when asked for salary expectations early in the interview?
Deflect with a question. When they ask what you are looking for, respond with this:
"Before I answer that, can you share the salary range budgeted for the role?"
Then stop talking. Let them answer.
This is not evasive. It is strategic. You are asking for information that already exists. Every role has a budget. You are simply asking them to share it before you show your hand.
How do you position yourself at the top of the salary range?
Once they share the range, do not immediately accept or counter. Ask the most important question in the entire negotiation:
"That is helpful. What skills or experience typically separate someone at the lower end of that range from someone at the top?"
This single sentence changes the entire dynamic. You shift the conversation from money to criteria. You learn exactly how to justify the top number. And you regain control of the negotiation.
Once they list the criteria, align yourself to it:
"Based on what you have described, that aligns closely with my experience. Given that, my expectation would be around the top of that range."
Then stop talking. No apology. No justification spiral. Silence signals confidence.
What if they refuse to share the salary range?
Some employers push back. They want your number first. If they insist, anchor to market value, not your history:
"For this type of role, based on scope and responsibility, I would expect something in the region of [market rate]."
Notice what you did not say. You did not reveal your current salary. You anchored to the market, not to your past. That is the difference between negotiating from strength and negotiating from a deficit.
How do you handle salary expectations when you are underqualified on paper?
If you do not tick every box on the job description, do not discount yourself. Frame your answer around impact, not credentials:
"I am aware I may not tick every box yet, but based on the impact I have delivered in similar roles, I would still be targeting the upper half of the range."
This positions you as self-aware, impact-led, and not desperate. Those three qualities matter more than a perfect CV match.
What salary script works when you are overqualified?
Keep it simple and senior:
"Given the scope we have discussed and the level I have operated at previously, I would expect to be at the top end of the range."
No over-explanation. No justification. The seniority of the statement is the justification.
Which questions move you from "candidate" to "top of the range"?
Before you state any number, ask two or three of these questions. They shift salary conversations from emotion to evidence.
Questions about role success:
- "What does success look like in the first 6 to 12 months?"
- "What problems would you expect the person in this role to solve quickly?"
- "What would make this hire a clear win for you?"
Questions about top performer differentiation:
- "What separates a good performer in this role from a great one?"
- "What capabilities justify someone being paid at the top of the band?"
- "What does the strongest person you have seen in this role do differently?"
Questions about scope and authority:
- "How much decision-making authority does this role have?"
- "What level of budget, influence, or leadership responsibility comes with it?"
These answers tell you exactly how to earn more. Senior candidates ask about risk, scope, and expectations. Junior ones avoid those topics entirely.
What mistakes cost you the most money in salary conversations?
Three mistakes account for the majority of lost salary:
- Leading with your current salary. This anchors you to your past, not your future value. Never volunteer this number.
- Offering a discount before they ask for one. Phrases like "I am flexible" or "I am open to negotiation" signal that your number is soft. State it and stop talking.
- Filling silence with apologies. After you state your expectation, the next person to speak loses leverage. Sit with the silence. It signals confidence.
The bottom line
Never reveal your current salary. Get the employer to share their range first, then use criteria-based questions to position yourself at the top.
What is your next step?
Salary negotiation is not theatre. It is adult decision-making. You now have six scripts that cover every scenario, from the first screening call to the final offer conversation. Use them.
The professionals who earn the most are not the ones who work the hardest. They are the ones who know how to communicate their value at the right moment.
If you want to see how your CV holds up before your next interview, try the free Six Figure CV tool. Upload your CV and get an instant score with specific fixes, built from 9,000+ executive interviews.
And if you are ready to work directly with me to land your next six-figure role, check out how we can work together.